Rights of Persons of Unsound Mind in Civil & Criminal Cases


Rights of Persons of Unsound Mind in Civil & Criminal Cases

Rights of Persons of Unsound Mind in Civil Cases:

Civil Procedure Code (CPC):

  1. Representation: Under Order XXXII of the CPC, a person of unsound mind must be represented by a "next friend" or a guardian. This ensures that the person's interests are adequately protected during the litigation.

  2. Appointment of Guardian: The court appoints a guardian for a person of unsound mind to manage their litigation matters. The guardian acts in the best interest of the person and protects their legal rights.

  3. Capacity to Sue: A person of unsound mind cannot file a lawsuit or defend themselves in a lawsuit without a guardian. The guardian files or defends the case on their behalf.

  4. Compromise and Settlement: Any compromise or settlement involving a person of unsound mind must be approved by the court to ensure it is fair and in the best interests of the person.

Rights of Persons of Unsound Mind in Criminal Cases:

Criminal Procedure Code (CRPC):

  1. Fitness to Stand Trial: Under Sections 328-339 of the CRPC, if a person accused of a crime is found to be of unsound mind and incapable of making a defense, the court may postpone the trial. The court conducts an inquiry to determine the mental condition of the accused.

  2. Medical Examination: The court can order a medical examination of the accused to assess their mental condition. If found of unsound mind, the accused may be sent to a mental health facility for treatment.

  3. Suspension of Proceedings: If the accused is found to be of unsound mind during the trial, the court can suspend the proceedings and may detain the accused in a mental health facility until they are fit to stand trial.

  4. Defense of Insanity: Section 84 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) provides the defense of insanity, stating that nothing is an offense if the person, at the time of committing the act, was incapable of knowing the nature of the act due to unsoundness of mind.

Indian Evidence Act:

  1. Competency to Testify: Section 118 of the Indian Evidence Act states that all persons, including those of unsound mind, are competent to testify unless they are unable to understand the questions or provide rational answers due to their mental condition.

  2. Examination Procedures: Special procedures may be used to examine witnesses of unsound mind, ensuring that their testimony is recorded in a manner that accommodates their mental condition.

Constitution of India:

  1. Right to Equality: Article 14 guarantees equality before the law and equal protection of the laws to all persons, including those of unsound mind.

  2. Right to Life and Personal Liberty: Article 21 ensures the right to life and personal liberty, which includes the right to receive appropriate mental health care and protection from inhumane treatment.

Mental Healthcare Act, 2017:

  1. Rights of Persons with Mental Illness: The Act provides comprehensive rights to persons with mental illness, including the right to access mental health care, live in the community, protection from cruel treatment, and confidentiality regarding their mental health condition.

  2. Informed Consent: Persons with mental illness have the right to informed consent regarding their treatment, except in certain situations where they are unable to give consent, and treatment is necessary.

  3. Advance Directives: The Act allows persons with mental illness to make advance directives specifying how they wish to be treated in case they lose the capacity to make decisions in the future.

  4. Legal Capacity: The Act recognizes the legal capacity of persons with mental illness to make decisions regarding their treatment and other personal matters, with support if needed.

These provisions collectively ensure that persons of unsound mind are given special protection and consideration in both civil and criminal legal proceedings in India.

Court Practice Community

WhatsApp Group Invite

Join WhatsApp Community 

Post a Comment